Download PDF The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal
The presented book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal we offer right here is not kind of typical book. You recognize, reviewing now doesn't mean to take care of the published book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal in your hand. You can get the soft data of The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal in your gizmo. Well, we imply that the book that we extend is the soft data of the book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal The material and all points are very same. The distinction is just the kinds of guide The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal, whereas, this problem will specifically pay.
The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal
Download PDF The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal
Checking out an e-book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal is sort of easy task to do every single time you really want. Also checking out every single time you desire, this task will not disrupt your other activities; many individuals commonly check out the e-books The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal when they are having the extra time. Exactly what regarding you? Exactly what do you do when having the downtime? Do not you spend for worthless things? This is why you have to get guide The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal as well as try to have reading behavior. Reviewing this publication The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal will not make you worthless. It will certainly offer a lot more perks.
Poses currently this The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal as one of your book collection! But, it is not in your bookcase compilations. Why? This is guide The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal that is given in soft file. You can download the soft documents of this magnificent book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal now as well as in the web link given. Yeah, different with the other individuals which search for book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal outside, you can get simpler to pose this book. When some people still walk right into the shop and also browse the book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal, you are here only stay on your seat and get the book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal.
While the other individuals in the store, they are not exactly sure to discover this The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal directly. It might require even more times to go shop by store. This is why we suppose you this site. We will certainly provide the best method as well as referral to get the book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal Also this is soft file book, it will certainly be convenience to bring The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal wherever or conserve in your home. The distinction is that you may not need move guide The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal area to area. You could require just copy to the other tools.
Currently, reading this stunning The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal will be much easier unless you get download and install the soft documents below. Just below! By clicking the link to download and install The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal, you could begin to obtain the book for your very own. Be the first proprietor of this soft data book The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal Make distinction for the others as well as get the initial to progression for The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise After A Thousand Years Of Decline, By Sanjeev Sanyal Here and now!
Hardcover Publisher: Viking (1200) ASIN: B00E7UXP5G
- Sales Rank: #3388732 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Viking
- Published on: 2009-09-16
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: .90" h x 5.70" w x 8.40" l, .80 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 230 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
Most helpful customer reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful.
Useful enough. But... Misleading title, dry and unengaging prose
By Abhinav Agarwal
Useful in its own right, but dry and uninviting prose render it a middling effort.
India was the most technologically advanced, the richest, the oldest, and certainly the most culturally advanced civilization from the beginning of recorded history till about a thousand years ago. It continued to remain the world's richest nation till the eighteenth century. Why India went into a state of decline a thousand years ago, why it continued to decline, and why it should see a renaissance now, starting with 1991, is a conundrum, even an impossibility some would argue. Of course there have been explanations. Those of a more socialist leaning argue against anything worthwhile in Indian civilization to begin with, marking it as a civilization bound to stagnate (as per D.D. Kosambi, eminent historian), and that anything worthwhile in India can be found to have originated only in the last thousand years - the ideological strains in that symphony are loud and clear. On the other hand, those who have made a more honest and detailed study of India and its civilization point out to its immense contributions in almost every sphere of life, including science, culture, language, mathematics, astronomy, urban planning, and more (see Michel Danino's "India's Culture and India's Future" for instance). Sanyal points out that the Indus Valley Civilization (more correctly the Indus Valley Saraswati Civilization, but not pertinent to the discussion in the book) was the largest, earliest, and most advanced example of urban town planning the world has known, with a level of standardization that would take five thousand years to better. Indians were adept at trading, and the world's oldest tidal dock can be found at Lothal (my post). Indians were trading with Sumerians and "India accounted for 33 per cent of the world economy in 1 A.D. However, "(B)etween AD 1000 and 1820, India's share of world GDP fell from 29 per cent to 16 per cent." It would fall to 4% by 1947, and sink to 3% by 1991. So, what caused the decline? That is, surprisingly, a tough nut to crack. A thousand years later we still do not have answers. Conjectures, yes. Ideologically framed theories, yes. But nothing that quite convincingly explains why. So, a book that has the words "India's Rise After a Thousand Years of Decline" should provide enough food for thought, or so I thought.
The author puts forth a conjecture or two, and the main thrust of that conjecture is that Indians turned inwards. They stopped being open to new ideas. Their "spirit of entrepreneurship" was eroded. "There are several independent signs of intellectual fossilization around the eleventh century" as well as "growing technological naivete after the eleventh century." Plausible, and true to an undeniable extent. It is tempting to rush forth to arguments that sound plausible enough to be acceptable and backed by just enough fact to pass initial muster. The most popular myth is that "the Muslim conquest of India was the result of a young and vigorous religion defeating an old pacifist civilization." This, the author points out, "is hardly borne out by the sequence of events." Furthermore, "(A)s Professor Pervez Amirali Hoodhboy puts it: 'One gets the impression that [Muslim] history's clock broke down somewhere during the fourteenth century and that plans for repair are, at best, vague.'" To sum, "by the time Muslim was rule was firmly established in India in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, Islamic civilization itself was past its peak." Therefore, the author argues that Islamic conquest cannot be blamed for India's decline. This story of civilizational decline is not unique to India. The Roman empire crumbled after the fifth century, unable to withstand the onslaught of an increasingly powerful Christian Church whose rise saw the library of Alexandria burned down by "Christian zealots in the late fourth century", the Greek philosopher Hypatia "killed by a Christian mob in Alexandria", and "Plato's academy shut down under the orders of Emperor Justinian in AD 526." Nearer home, China had naval technology "generations ahead of the Europe" in the early 1400s. Yet a cultural attitude saw this knowledge stagnate and innovation stifled. So, India was not alone in this civilizational decline.
The author argues that "it was civilizational decline that led to foreign domination rather than the other way around." And here is where the biggest problem lies with the book. For two primary reasons. Firstly, while the Indian civilization may well have been at its peak and suffering from the not unexpected signs of complacency by the time the last millennium began, there is nothing in the decades or centuries preceding it to point to an imminent decline. There is near unanimity on the tenth and eleventh centuries as the beginnings of India's decline - not a gradual decay into obscurantism that accelerated in the second millennium. The second is the contradiction in the book itself - if civilizational decline was well and truly underway by 1000 CE or thereabouts, it would have been unusual to find any exceptional centers of learning in the subcontinent. However that was not the case. Far from it. You had the university at Takshila, established in the sixth century BC, destroyed by the "White Huns (Epththalites) around 460 AD." This was followed by the total destruction of the world's largest university at Nalanda in 1193 CE by Bakhtiyar Khilji, and finally the complete destruction of Ujjaini - "a major center for mathematics, literature, philosophy and astronomy" - in 1235 by Sultan Iltumish. A civilization in decay and stagnation cannot be expected to either have had the greatest centers of learning in the medieval world, nor would it be expected to stave off the military advances of Islamic invaders for several centuries, that it did, and which the author points to in his book. This resistance, lasting several centuries, against Islamic conquest, is unparalleled in human history, and defies logic to credit a decaying, declining civilization with being capable of mounting. The book's argument is undermined by its own prose.
What is a plausible explanation is that the steady, unremitting, and murderous onslaught of foreign invaders led to Indian civilization retreating into a survival mode, closing itself to innovations, questions, invigoration, closing itself to adaptation in order to survive. In other words, foreign domination led to a rapid shrinking of the space for openness and this defined, rather than caused, the thousand years of decline. To argue otherwise is somewhat of a classic post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. This story of the thousand-year decline takes up one chapter, less than thirty pages in the book. That is perhaps the single biggest weakness and flaw of this book - a distinct imbalance between the premise of the title and the contents of the book, weakened further by a fairly weak line of argumentation in itself.
The rest of the book takes the reader through the emergence of the Indian middle-class, the roots of which can be seen as early as the eighteenth century. The post Independence period saw the full brutality of the "Nehru-Mahalonobis rate of growth" visit Indians, which left economic growth mired at less than four percent and hundreds of millions in abject poverty. While socialism may have been the fashion of the age when Pandit Nehru ruled India, "but the blind following fashion is no excuse for poor judgment." Milton Friedman, Nobel laureate, had as early as in 1956 had pointed out the fundamental flaw and danger in having an able mathematician like Mahalonobis "apply themselves to economic planning." Mahalonobis was also shown to be a plagiarizer by none other than the maverick of Indian politics, then a young, 19 year old Subramanian Swamy!
Much of the book is basically ground covered several times before by several other books, most notably by Gurcharan Das' "India Unbound". There has been no shortage of books on the topic of India's rise, and each has tried to add something to this narrative, some successfully so, some less so (Edward Luce's "In Spite of the Gods" being a particularly nasty example, while Anand Giridharadas' "India Calling" being a paint-by-numbers exercise in enervating mediocrity). This book's shining moments can be found when discussing India's educational and legal systems, both of which have failed the Indian citizen. What is however lacking throughout the book is both the engaging nature that someone like Mark Tully brings through his anecdotes and first-person accounts, as well as the vice-like grasp over facts that Arun Shourie can hold the reader with. If you want to be educated on the utter banality of horror that the Indian bureaucracy is, you need do no more than read Arun Shourie's "Governance". The morbidly fascinating morass of the Indian judiciary is brought to the fore in "Courts and Their Judgments". So, even though the book is arranged somewhat thematically, the discussion fails to cohere, flitting from one topic to the other, and is marked by a lack of an underlying narrative fabric to bring these together into a story. It remains a set of longish essays put together into a book.
On a slightly mischievous note, I must conclude by observing that the author, a Bengali, cannot help but point the decline of the once glorious city of Calcutta (now Kolkata) as symbolic of the decline of an entire civilization!
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
The Indian Rennaissance
By K.V.Veloo
The Indian Renaissance-India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline by Sanjeev Sanyal
The author is a Rhodes Scholar and is based in Singapore as a Chief Economist of a bank. He is also an Adjunct Fellow of the Institute of Policy Studies at the National University of Singapore (NUS).
I have read a similar topic, “India from Midnight to the Millennium” by Shashi Tharoor,” and “India Unbound" by Gurchan Das. I found Sanjeev's book an easy read and to comprehend.
For nearly 50 years, since India got its independence in 1947, India was weighed down by Nehru's socialist economic theory and practice.
Nehru was captivated by a mathematician, Chandra Mahaalonobis who devised a scientific input and output model "that aimed to speed up a country's development through state intervention". It failed because it did not take into consideration the power of "innovation.
It was only with the opening of India in the 1990s that there was a paradigm shift in both as an economy and as a civilisation: thanks to Narashima Rao and Dr Manmohan Singh who dared to break away from the old traditional malaise. It was short lived because of political bickering, bureaucracy and corruption in all sectors of the government. India has not fully recovered from it.
Still, with all its woes India has made to the membership of industrialised clubs. It is sad that it lost 50 good years.
The book is an easy read.
KVVeloo
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
Fresh perspective!!!
By PRAMIT RASTOGI
A good book to make sense of the rise, fall and now the current rise of India. Sanjeev Sanyal's writing is thorough, yet easy to read. Look forward to reading his other books.
The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal PDF
The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal EPub
The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal Doc
The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal iBooks
The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal rtf
The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal Mobipocket
The Indian Rennaissance: India's Rise after a Thousand Years of Decline, by Sanjeev Sanyal Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar